|
Post by Fawnkit on Aug 23, 2010 14:12:39 GMT -5
In Fading Echos, Jayfeather took Poppyfrost to the Moonpool, and Breezepelt attacked him. Honeyfern saved him, but why wasnt Hollyleaf helping? They coould have both saved him, but instead it was just Honeyfern. Why? It's easy: Either Hollyleaf is alive, doesnt care about her brother, or joined the Dark Forest.
Those are my thaughts.
|
|
|
Post by Mooncloud on Oct 13, 2010 22:51:28 GMT -5
The Erin's refuse to confirm whether Hollyleaf is dead or alive... so that leads me to believe she is alive. I think she survived and joined the tribe. If she is dead, then my only explanation is that she believes that she and her brothers shouldn't exist and is choosing not to interfere (loves her brothers and so does not hurt them, but can't bring herself to help them since it goes against the code).
(fyi, Jayfeather followed Poppyfrost to the Moonpool)
|
|
|
Post by Sunnyfrost on Oct 24, 2010 20:20:40 GMT -5
that and it was in Fourth Apprentice not Fading Echoes ^.^
|
|
|
Post by Rainstar on Oct 27, 2010 16:50:01 GMT -5
yeah, at the end of fourth apprentice and hollyleaf doesn't join Dark Forest
|
|
|
Post by Brownfur on Oct 27, 2010 22:09:28 GMT -5
Rainsong: How do you know that?
|
|
|
Post by Rainstar on Oct 28, 2010 19:35:23 GMT -5
because, the fifth book of omen of the stars is called the forgotten warrior, where one cat returns home to the lake. that is probably Hollyleaf
|
|
|
Post by Hawkstar on Oct 28, 2010 19:56:10 GMT -5
Yeah, I agree with Rainsong.(I usually do) Who else would the forgotten Warrior be? Ashfur? Anyway, I knew it was gonna be Hollyleaf when I first heard the title many weeks ago.
|
|
|
Post by Hawkstar on Oct 28, 2010 19:56:44 GMT -5
The Erin's refuse to confirm whether Hollyleaf is dead or alive... so that leads me to believe she is alive. I think she survived and joined the tribe. If she is dead, then my only explanation is that she believes that she and her brothers shouldn't exist and is choosing not to interfere (loves her brothers and so does not hurt them, but can't bring herself to help them since it goes against the code). (fyi, Jayfeather followed Poppyfrost to the Moonpool) How would she join the TRIBE! Really, do you truely think that!
|
|
|
Post by Brownfur on Oct 29, 2010 12:36:48 GMT -5
Me too. But it's not a fact that she returns, just a probability.
It's always possible, but why would she even want to join the tribe?
|
|
|
Post by Hawkstar on Oct 29, 2010 15:14:47 GMT -5
It is a TOTAL fact that she returns in the Forgotten Warrior!
|
|
|
Post by Rainstar on Oct 29, 2010 17:38:23 GMT -5
yeah, but she returns as a villain
|
|
|
Post by Brownfur on Oct 31, 2010 12:46:24 GMT -5
If the Erins haven't said that she's returning, it is [glow=black,2,300][shadow=black,left,300][shadow=black,right,300]NNNOOOTTT [/b][/glow][/shadow][/shadow][/color][/u][/size] a fact!!!!!!!!!!!!! And, even if it were, it's not a fact that she returns in The Forgotten Warrior. She might return in the end of Sign of the Moon.[/center] Happy Halloween!
|
|
|
Post by brownstripe on Nov 3, 2010 19:40:29 GMT -5
Here's another thing: In the prolouge, she wasn't seen chatting with The Thunderclan Starclan members. But actually, they were GOSSIPING about her. It's MOST LIKELY she either went to the dark forest or is alive.
|
|
|
Post by Rainstar on Dec 21, 2010 22:54:34 GMT -5
YOU NEVER KNOW!
|
|
|
Post by Mooncloud on Dec 22, 2010 21:40:38 GMT -5
What we know:
Sunrise: Hollyleaf goes under tunnel. Jayfeather has a vision that she is buried alive and tries to stop her but is too late. (So far sounding like she's dead)
Fourth Apprentice: Don't see her in Star Clan. Her status changed from 'died' to 'disappeared' in the tunnels (live or dead up for grabs). Towards the end there are a lot of Star Clan cats, but Hollyleaf doesn't make an appearance (Jayfeather tried not to look in case he didn't see her)
Night Whispers- While with Cinderheart, Lionblaze has a flashback to the day Hollyleaf goes down the tunnel. Not seen in Star Clan BUT not seen in the Dark Forest either!
Bottom Line: Jayfeather and Lionblaze (the only witnesses) believe their sister is dead... but I'm starting to think she isn't... either that or she is with the ancient cats cause so far she has yet to make an appearance anywhere.
|
|